Wednesday, April 15, 2020

INDIANS ONCE PIONEERS OF SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY ARE ONLY FOLLOWERS TODAY


INDIANS ONCE PIONEERS OF SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY   ARE  ONLY FOLLOWERS TODAY--Karmanyeva Adhkariste!



[Compilation   for a discourse at Sri Ganesha Temple, Nashville, TN, USA by N.R. Srinivasan, April  2020]


‘The Vedas address all aspects of existence through Dharma, the natural laws that uphold the universe, which reflect not only matter and energy but life, mind and consciousness. As such, the Vedas constitute what could be called a science in the modern sense of the word and much more. We can find among the Vedic sciences a whole range of sciences from astronomy and chemistry to psychology and surgery, extending to astrology and to the science of Yoga itself. We can call this integral approach to both the spiritual and material sciences as ‘Vedic science.’ “ writes  David Frawley.



 “Some of the early Contributions of Indians to Science are geometry of the Vedic altars, the invention of zero in India, Yoga psychology, and Indian technology of steel-making that went into the manufacture of the best swords. But the most astonishing contributions are: Sanskrit grammar, binary numbers of Pigala, music theory, combinatorics, algebra, earliest astronomy, and the physics of Kaāda with its laws of motion.



Of these, Kaāda is the least known. He may not have presented his ideas as mathematical equations, but he attempted something that no physicist to date has dared to do: he advanced a system that includes space, time, matter, as well as observers. He also postulated four types of atoms, two with mass (like proton and electron) and two without (like neutrino and photon), and the idea of invariance. A thousand or more years after Kaāda, Āryabhaa postulated that earth rotated and advanced the basic idea of relativity of motion.



History reveals istory reveals Kerala School of Mathematics had   developed calculus long   before Newton and    Leibniz heralded the Scientific Revolution that was to change the world-- the discovery of Infinite series and Calculus.  Royal Australia College of Surgeons in Melbourne, Australia has a prominent display of a statue of Suśruta (600 BCE) with the caption “Father of Surgery”. The ancient Ayurveda texts include the notion of germs and inoculation and also postulate mind-body connection, which has become an important area of contemporary research. (Please go through my detailed discourse on the subject).



There are also anomalous statements in Indian texts whose origin is not understood. Just to mention a few: the correct speed of light, the correct distance to the sun, cosmological cycles that broadly correspond to the numbers accepted currently, the fact that the sun and the moon are approximately 108 times their respective diameters from the earth, the correct number of species on earth (about 8.4 million), and so on. Historians either ignore them or say that they are extraordinary coincidences. 



There are also indirect ways that Indian ideas led to scientific advance. Mendeleev was inspired by the two-dimensional structure of the Sanskrit alphabet to propose a similar two-dimensional structure of chemical elements. Erwin Schrödinger, a founder of quantum theory, credited ideas in the Upanishads for the key notion of superposition that was to bring about the quantum revolution in physics that changed chemistry, biology, and technology’” says  Indologist Subhash Kak. We will talk about these more, later    in this compilation from the voices of world reputed Western Scientists.  



This is just a cross-section of what ancient India had offered regarding science and technology. From advanced hydraulic engineering of the Indus civilization to the naval technology of the Chola Dynasty, India has been influenced by our scriptures to focus on science and technology, explore and   benefit the world as pioneers.



But later brainwashed by foreign rulers, Western educated Indian Scientists not only neglected serious study of our scriptures but also dismissed them as myths while Western scientists seriously focused on them became World Leaders while Indians continue as their followers.   Such an awakening just started but caught in political fights the pessimism and negligence continues. both at individual as well as the Government level.



The Government of India, though late than never, is planning to set up a Vedic Research Centre that would collect both original works and those related to the religious texts from across the globe, a repository aimed at bridging the gap between ancient wisdom and modern science. Ujjain-based Maharshi Sandipani Rashtriya Vedavidya Pratishthan (MSRVP) — the institute   would conduct research to “unearth the scientific and therapeutic knowledge buried” in the Vedas.



Here are some excerpts from Vedas that provide clues to deep scientific concepts hidden within them. Unfortunately, due to thousand years of slavery, burning of Hindu universities and libraries by barbarians and then demands for tackling issues of survival first, there remains a lot of work to be done to rediscover the Vedic sciences. However, sufficient clues exist to justify why this rediscovery would be worthwhile. 



Vedas not being dogmatic in nature and containing eternal truths, do not try to spoon-feed us. Thus Vedas would contain seeds for all forms of knowledge and would urge humans to explore further. Because in the Vedic framework, it is our efforts that can provide us bliss. There may be few defective seeds too that need to be discarded.



CREATION OF THE UNIVERSE



Vilenkin starts his postulation on creation referring to Vedas of 3000 years old. Vedas say creation is of repetitive nature and say “Yathapoorvam akalpayat”-Brahman created the Universe every time as it was before. In the model Steinhardt and Turok describe, universes periodically collide with each other, with each collision acting like a new Big Bang. Whereas the standard Big Bang model features a single moment of creation, their model — as with Penrose’s — suggests that we live in “a universe that is made and remade forever,” as Steinhardt puts it. Cosmologist Alexander Vilenkin believes the Big Bang wasn't a one-off event, but merely one of a series of big bangs creating an endless number of bubble universes. Vilenkin also feels that explosive form of cosmic expansion — must have had a beginning, too. By this logic, our universe also had a beginning since it was spawned by an inflationary process that is eternal into the future but not the past.  While Penrose suggests creation as cyclic Vikenkin suggests of repetitive nature. Yathapoorvam akalpayat also means “of repetitive nature” only.



For many physicists, the beginning of the universe is uncomfortable, because it suggests that something must have caused the beginning, that there should be some cause outside the universe. In fact, we now have models where that’s not necessary—the universe spontaneously appears, quantum mechanically. The description of the creation of the universe from nothing is given in terms of the laws of physics. In quantum physics, events do not necessarily have a cause, just some probability. As such, there is some probability for the universe to pop out of “nothing.”  Nasadeeya sookta says in the beginning there was nothing except Brahman alone whence he started his work of   creation feeling lonely!



MOTION OF EARTH

Rig Veda 10.22.14
“This earth is devoid of hands and legs, yet it moves ahead. All the objects over the earth also move with it. It moves around the sun.
In this mantra,
Kshaa = Earth (refer Nigantu 1.1)
Ahastaa = without hands
Apadee = without legs
Vardhat = moves ahead
Shushnam Pari = Around the sun
Pradakshinit = revolves

Rig Veda 10.149.1
“The sun has tied Earth and other planets through attraction and moves them around itself as if a trainer moves newly trained horses around itself holding their reins.”

In this manta:

Yantraih = through reins
Prithiveem = Earth
Aramnaat = Ties
Dyaam Andahat = Other planets in sky as well
Atoorte = Unbreakable
Baddham = Holds
Ashwam Iva Adhukshat = Like horses



GRAVITATIONAL FORCE

Rig Veda 8.12.28

“O Indra! putting forth your mighty rays, which possess the qualities of gravitation and attraction-illumination and motion – keep up the entire universe in order through the Power of your attraction.”

Rig Veda 1.6.5, Rig Veda 8.12.30

“O God, You have created this Sun. You possess infinite power. You are upholding the sun and other spheres and render them steadfast by your power of attraction.

Yajur Veda 33.43

“The sun moves in its own orbit in space taking along with itself the mortal bodies like earth through force of attraction.”

Rig Veda 1.35.9

“The sun moves in its own orbit but holding earth and other heavenly bodies in a manner that they do not collide with each other through force of attraction.

Rig Veda 1.164.13

“Sun moves in its orbit which itself is moving. Earth and other bodies move around sun due to force of attraction, because sun is heavier than them.

Atharva Veda 4.11.1

“The sun has held the earth and other planets”

LIGHT OF MOON

Rig Veda 1.84.15
“The moving moon always receives a ray of light from sun”

Rig Veda 10.85.9
“Moon decided to marry. Day and Night attended its wedding. And sun gifted his daughter “Sun ray” to Moon.”

ECLIPSE

Rig Veda 5.40.5

“O Sun! When you are blocked by the one whom you gifted your own light (moon), then earth gets scared by sudden darkness.”



“SCIENCE OF BUILDING SHIPS AND AIRPLANES”

Swami Dayananda has detailed Mantras regarding these in his Vedic commentary and Introduction to Vedas” (1876). The scientists of IISc., concluded that the mechanism of airplane as suggested by Dayananda is feasible. The first manned plane was built 20 years after death of Swami Dayananda.  Readers may review “Introduction to Vedas” by Swami Dayanand or interpretations of following mantras: Rig Veda 1.116.3, 1.116.4, 10.62.1, 1.116.5, 1.116.6, 1.34.2, 1.34.7, 1.48.8 etc.



SCIENCE OF TELEGRAPHY

Rig Veda 1.119.10

“With the help of bipolar forces (Asvins), you should employ telegraphic apparatus made of good conductor of electricity. It is necessary for efficient military operations but should be used with caution.”



SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE HIDDEN IN ANCIENT VEDA MANTRAS & SUTRAS

(Extracts from my Compilation of Gems of Wisdom from Vedas and Upanishads--Hindu Reflections)



Ancient scientific knowledge is deeply hidden in our Veda mantras bthat is amazing. I quote below specific mantras from Rigveda and Vaiseshika Sutras on Gravitational Force attributed by the West to the discovery by Sir Isaac Newton:



Vedic Mantras on Gravity



Rigveda Mantra 1.6 73 speaks of gravitational force:



अजो कषां दाधार पर्थिवीं तस्तम्भ दयां मन्त्रेभिः सत्यैः |
परिया पदानि पश्वो नि पाहि विश्वायुरग्ने गुहा गुहं गाः || ||

ajo na(h) kasham dādhāra pthivī ta(t)stambha dyā mantrebhi satyai | priyā padāni paśvo ni pāhi viśvāyuraghne ghuhā ghuha ghā ||

The unborn force or field (aja) keeps us (nah) rooted to Earth (kshaam). The same omnipresent force (tat) or field holds (Sthmbha) the Earth (prithveem) in space (dyaam),



Rig Veda 8.12.28

यदा ते हर्यता हरी वाव्र्धाते दिवे-दिवे | आदित ते विश्वा भुवनानि येमिरे || 28 ||



Yadaa te haryatā harī vāvdhāte dive-dive | ādita te viśvā bhuvanāni yemire

“O Indra! By putting forth your mighty rays, which possess the qualities of gravitation and attraction-illumination and motion – keep up the entire universe in order through the Power of your attraction.”





AN EXTRAORDINARY MANTRA OF THE RIG VEDA FOCUSED ON SCIENCE:
Scientist Vamadeva Gautama, who is called a Rishi, declared this eternal truth in Rigveda Listen to him, O human being!! This is true even now!
na pramiye savitur-devasya tadyathā viśvam bhuvanam dhārayișyati |
yat pŗthivyā varimannā svanguri
varșman diva suvati satyam asya tat || Rig Veda 5.54.4 ||



Never doubt (na pramiye), capacities such as (tadyathā), of the glorious Sun (savitur-devasya), the celestial objects (viśvam), and the earth (bhuvanam) sustains (holds, protects, carries) (dhārayișyati). How, is because, (yat), of the earth (pŗthivyāh), though extremely huge (varimat), a ring for himself (svanguri) (has made). And constantly (varșman) divah (in space) set in motion (suvati). What is mentioned here is the truth (satyam asya tat).





Never underestimate the capabilities of the glorious Savita (the Sun). He is holding objects in space as he is holding the Earth. How is the Sun holding the Earth? The Earth is huge!  Yet the Sun has made a ring and has set the Earth in constant motion around him in space. This alone is the truth!




VAISHESHIKA SUTRA  (V.S,)



Why does  an object held fall when you let go?



To describe this first of all Sutra V.S. 5.1.6 states: आत्मकर्म हस्तसंयोगाश्च Aatmahasta samyogascha --Action of body and its members is also from conjunction with the hand.



As the above Sutra describes that it is due to conjunction with hand object remains. Then the next Sutra describes that in the absence of conjunction, falling results due to Gravity.



Sutra 5.1.7 states: संयोगभावे गुरुत्वात्पतनम (Samyogabhavea gurutva utpatana)m  --In the absence of conjunction falling results from Gravity.Thus it clearly recognizes objects fall downward due to Gravity.



Why does an object thrown in air fall after sometime?

Then Vaishesika Sutra 5.1.17 discuss role of Gravity in falling of moving objects. It gives through the analogy of arrow. First it gives mechanism of arrow projection in this Sutra :

नोदनाद्यभिषोः कर्म तत्कर्मकारिताच्च संस्कारादुत्तरं तथोत्तरमुत्तरं ।। 

 (nodanaadyabhisho karma tatkarmakaaritaccha samskaaraaduttaram tathottaramuttaram cha) --The first action of arrow is from impulse; the next is resultant energy produced by the first action, and similarly the next next.

Then it explains logically why it falls in next Sutra. 5,1,18

संस्काराभावे गुरुत्वात्पतनम  (samskaarabhave gurutvaat patanam) --In the absence of resultant propulsive energy generated by action, falling results from Gravity.



Why does water fall (and rise)?

Rig Veda 8.12.30

यदा सूर्यममुं दिवि शुक्रं जयोतिरधारयः |  आदित ते विश्वा भुवनानि येमिरे || || 30 ||



yadā sūryamamu divi śukra jyotiradhāraya |  ādiata te visvaa bhuva-naani yemire   || 30 ||



O God, You have created this Sun. You possess infinite power. You are upholding the sun and other spheres and render them steadfast by your power of attraction.”



Then the Sutras 5.2.3 discusses cause of falling of water from sky. अपां संयोगाभावे गुरुत्वात्पतनम  (Apaam samyogabhave gurutvaat patanam)-- The falling of water in absence of conjunction is due to Gravity.Then it discusses flow of water in Sutra 5.2.4

द्रवथ्वास्यन्दनम् (drvyaasyaandanam)--Flowing results from fluidity.



Then it discusses why water rises in 5.2.



नाड्यो वायुसंयोगादारोहणम् (naadyo vyusamyogaadaarohanam)--The Sun’s rays (cause) the ascent of water through conjunction with air.



Thus from above Sutras, we can see how our ancient rishis were very clear in their scientific thoughts and postulations.   Vaisheshika Sutra clearly discusses Gravity and uses the word Gurutva repeatedly to mean it. Gravity is translated as”Gurutva” in Hindi and Sanskrit as the vernacular scientific translation for Gravity. Gurutva means force which arises due to mass.

“Chatvaari Sringo trayo asya paadaa dveseersha sapta hastaaso asya | Triddhaa baddho vrishbho roraveeti maho devo martyaa aavivesa ||

The syllable Om conceived as the Bull possesses five horns, three feet and two heads and seven hands (of oval shape). This Bull connected in a threefold manner, eloquently declares the Supreme. The Self-luminous Deity has entered the mortals everywhere.  There are different   explanations of this mantra about which I have talked about before.  But one that is relevant in the context is the first line simply symbolically represents Brahman as a Kalpa Purusha. We all know Brahman is often referred as Time or Kaala and Samvatsara (Samvatasrova apaam pushpam; Kaalaaya namah).  Without explaining its deeper meanings, if we simply write the numbers continuously mentioned in the mantra, it represents 4320000000 Human Years that is Kalpa. 4 comes from four horns, 3 comes from three feet, 2 comes from two heads and 7 zeros that follow comes from seven hands in oval (0) shape! This Brahman appears again and again for each Kalpa with his band of controllers to revive and rule the universe which is indicated by the roar of the bull.



[1 kalpa=4320000x1000=4320000000. Brahman is compared to a mystic bull with 4horns, 3 feet 2 heads band 7 tongues that 4 3 2 and 7 zeros represented in 4- by -2-0000000   as explained above]



Hanuman Chalisa describes Hanuman’s leap to Sun thus:

"Yug sahasra yojan par Bhanu! Leelyo taahi madhur phal janu!!
1 Yug = 12000 divine years
1 Sahasra = 1000
1 Yojan = 8 Miles
Yug x Sahasra x Yojan = par Bhanu
12000 x 1000 x 8 miles = (Towards Sun) 96,000,000 miles 
1 mile = 1.6kms
96,000,000 miles x 1.6kms = 1,536,000,000 km/96,000,000 miles to Sun

NASA says that, this is the exact distance between Earth and Sun (Bhanu).  That proves tha Hanuman   did jump to the Planet Sun, thinking it as a sweet fruit (Madhur phal). It is really interesting how accurate and meaningful our ancient scriptures are. Unfortunately, it is hardly recognized or interpreted accurately or realized by any country in today’s world. 



How one Yuga cycle=12000 Divine Years?

The duration of the universe was fixed by the Supreme as 12000 years each of which was 360 human years so that the whole period is 4320000 human years. This duration was divided into four ages which are 4000, 3000, 2000 and 1000 respectively for Krita, Treta, Dvapara and Kali. After each yuga there is a period of darkness. This was 800, 600, 400 and 200 respectively. All together 10000+2000 makes 12000 divine Years;

All these can’t be accidental but based on Scientific Vision conveyed through Divine Foresight Vision of our sages. There are many such mantras and slokas that may contain scientific information that need to be researched and explained.  In this context please go through a brief scientific history of Indian Science by Subhash Kak delivered to the Indian Science Congress which I have elaborated in my earlier discourse on Hindu’s Contribution to Science and Technology in Early and Medieval Times.



SIX GREAT WESTERN SCIENTISTS WERE INFLUENCED BY HINDU SCRIPTURES

We’ve seen scientists dishing out people with religious beliefs, and vice versa. While religion might not be “logical” to some, but Sanatana Dharma of India has proven to have some science behind it. And as such, there are scientists who have been influenced by Hinduism. Here are some of the international figures in the world of science who have taken inspiration from various Hindu Scriptures about their influences and Hindu Dharma. These are: 1. Erwin Schrödinger; 2. Werner Heisenberg; 3. Robert Oppenheimer; 4. Niels Bohr; 5. Carl Sagan and 6. Nikola Tesla.



Please recall Schrödinger’s cat.   It is a very famous experiment, and the inferences have a great value in the world of science. That was one of the many scientific experiments Erwin Schrödinger is known for.  He in his biography and some of the works he has published, reveals the influence of Hindu Dharma:



“This life of yours which you are living is not merely a piece of this entire existence, but in a certain sense the whole; only this whole is not so constituted that it can be surveyed in one single glance. This, as we know, is what the Brahmins [wise men or priests in the Vedic tradition] express in that sacred, mystic formula which is yet really so simple and so clear; tat tvam asi, this is you. Or, again, in such words as “I am in the east and the west, I am above and below, I am this entire world.” [Schrödinger,’Meine Weltansicht’ (My View of the World), 1961]

“The multiplicity is only apparent. This is the doctrine of the Upanishads. And not of the Upanishads only. The mystical experience of the union with God regularly leads to this view, unless strong prejudices stand in the West.”[Erwin Schrödinger, What is Life? p. 129, Cambridge University Press]



“From the early great Upanishads, the recognition Atman = Brahman (the personal self-equals the omnipresent, all-comprehending eternal self) was in Indian thought considered, far from being blasphemous, to represent, the quintessence of deepest insight into the happenings of the world. The striving of all the scholars of Vedanta was, after having learned to pronounce with their lips, really to assimilate in their minds this grandest of all thoughts.” [From essay on determinism and free will]

“Most of my ideas & theories are heavily influenced by Vedanta



“There is no kind of framework within which we can find consciousness in the plural; this is simply something we construct because of the temporal plurality of individuals, but it is a false construction… The only solution to this conflict insofar as any is available to us at all lies in the ancient wisdom of the Upanishad.” (Mein Leben, Meine Weltansicht [My Life, My World View] (1961), Chapter 4)



Werner Heisenberg   is a key figure in the world of quantum mechanics.  The German Nobel Prize winner for Physics is believed to have understood much of quantum mechanisms through his mystical experience in Hindu dharma. Here are some of his citations:

In Uncommon Wisdom: Conversations With Remarkable People (1988), Fritjof Capra writes about the conversation between Rabindranath Tagore and Werner Heisenberg: “He began to see that the recognition of relativity, interconnectedness, and impermanence as fundamental aspects of physical reality, which had been so difficult for himself and his fellow physicists, was the very basis of Indian spiritual traditions.  While he was working on quantum theory he went to India to lecture and was a guest of Tagore. He talked a lot with Tagore about Indian philosophy.   These talks had helped him a lot with his work in physics because they showed him that all these new ideas in quantum physics were in fact not all that crazy. He realized there was, in fact, a whole culture that subscribed to very similar ideas. Heisenberg said that this was a great help for him. Niels Bohr had a similar experience when he went to China--The Holographic Paradigm (pg. 217-218).



He has also been seen quoted a couple of times saying; “After the conversations about Hindu philosophy, some of the ideas of Quantum Physics that had seemed so crazy suddenly made more sense.”

 “Quantum Theory” will not look ridiculous to people who have read Vedanta.”



Father of an atomic bomb, Julius Robert Oppenheimer was a theoretical physicist and was the head of the lab when the first atomic bomb was invented (Manhattan Project). Bhagavad Gita, Mahabharata and Indian historical facts have influenced Oppenheimer. He also studied Sanskrit and read Bhagavad Gita in Sanskrit itself. Here are his quotes:



Access to the Vedas is the greatest privilege this century may claim over all previous centuries.



The general notions about human understanding… which are illustrated by discoveries in atomic physics are not in the nature of things wholly unfamiliar, wholly unheard of or new. Even in our own culture, they have a history, and in Buddhist and Hindu thought a more considerable and central place. What we shall find [in modern physics] is an exemplification, an encouragement, and a refinement of old wisdom.



The juxtaposition of Western civilization’s most terrifying scientific achievement with the most dazzling description of the mystical experience given to us by the Bhagavad Gita, India’s greatest literary monument.



The Bhagavad Gita… is the most beautiful philosophical song existing in any known tongue.” [“Sacred Jewels of Yoga: Wisdom from India’s Beloved Scriptures, Teachers, Masters, and Monks”]



Neils Henrik David Bo another Nobel Peace prize winner and  the Danish physicist is known for his tremendous contribution in atomic structure and quantum theory. In Stephen Pother’s book God Is Not One (pg. 144), Neil Bohr has quoted: “I go into the Upanishads to ask questions.”



American astronomer, cosmologist, astrophysicist, astrobiologist and philosopher, Carl Sagan’s contributions to cosmology and modern space science are unprecedented. He was a devout Hindu and has been seen quoting:



“The Hindu religion is the only one of the world’s great faiths dedicated to the idea that the Cosmos itself undergoes an immense, indeed an infinite, number of deaths and rebirths. It is the only religion in which the time scales correspond, to those of modern scientific cosmology. Its cycles run from our ordinary day and night to a day and night of Brahma, 8.64 billion years long. Longer than the age of the Earth or the Sun and about half the time since the Big Bang. And there are much longer time scales still.” [Carl Sagan, Cosmos]



“The most elegant and sublime of these is a representation of the creation of the universe at the beginning of each cosmic cycle, a motif known as the cosmic dance of Lord Shiva. The god called in this manifestation Nataraja, the Dance King. In the upper right hand is a drum whose sound is the sound of creation. In the upper left hand is a tongue of flame, a reminder that the universe, now newly created, with billions of years from now will be utterly destroyed.” [Carl Sagan, Cosmos, pages 213-214]



A millennium before Europeans were willing to divest themselves of the Biblical idea that the world was a few thousand years old, the Mayans were thinking of millions and the Hindus billions.” [Carl Sagan, Cosmos, pages 213-214]

Nikola Tesla (though disputed) is perhaps the greatest scientist (debatable for sure) ever lived and his inventions have given a great contribution to mankind; he was a pioneer in many fields. From Tesla Coil to Radio to Alternate Current to Telephone. HHHHe has been seen quoting Vedanta concepts:



“All perceptible matter comes from a primary substance, or tenacity beyond conception, filling all space, the Akasha or aluminiferous ether, which is acted upon by the life-giving Prana or creative force, calling into existence, in never-ending cycles, all things and phenomena.” [Man’s Greatest Achievement, John J. O’Neal., & Prodigal Genius, The Life of Nikola Tesla, 1944]

[References: wiki.com, teslasociety.com, hawkfeed.com, aumamen.com]



In this context please go through my various discourses dealing with the subject Hindus Contribution to Science and Technology.  It is unfortunate this progressive research and discovery in Science and Technology abruptly became few and far between after medieval period. The West awakened after Renaissance peeping into Wisdom of Vedas and Upanishads became leaders in the field.  It is a pity Noble Laureates from India are insignificant compared the West.



Jagadish Chandra Bose was the first to show wireless signaling in 1895.  Satyendranath Bose sent his work on the statistics of quanta of light photons to Albert Einstein.  Pioneer work in Quantum Optics and coherence was done by E. C. George Sudarshan. G N Ramachandran was the most deserving scientist for Nobel Prize for the work on bio-molecular structures and Crystallography.  Narinder Singh Kapany was the most deserving Nobel Prize winner for the work related to the transmission of light in fibers for optical communication.  Homi Bhabha’s name was suggested as many as four times in 1950s. It is very sad and astonishing that Indian scientists and their work is not recognized at International level. It is unfortunate Scientists like J.C. Bose and G. N. Ramachandran   were ignored! Of course Nobel Prize is not the only recognition of talents of science!



No doubt many Indian Scientists at present are also contented priding in the past glory or are bogged down in political turmoil without burning for shining!



India is also no stranger to prominent figures citing ancient Hindu texts like the Puranas and Vedas as ironclad evidence of the country’s technological prowess. Science Minister of India Harsh Vardhan last year said ancient Greeks took credit from India for early mathematical principles and misquoted Stephen Hawking as praising the Vedas for discoveries greater than Einstein’s theory of relativity. Economist Kaushik Basu says: "For a nation to progress it is important for people to spend time on science, mathematics and literature instead of spending time showing that 5,000 years ago their ancestors did science, Mathematics and literature. This trend is increasing now-a days. We have enough Sishyas (followers) but not Gurus as in the past.



Please go through the analysis by Hari Pulakkat published in Economic Times in 2013, suitably edited:

“Why an Indian hasn’t won — since CV Raman — a Nobel Prize in science for work done in India   A Nobel Prize is not a life-time achievement award. It is an award for blazing a trail. While a Nobel Prize is not the only yardstick for judging an individual’s research work, it is important for judging a country or even a top-ranking research institution.



No quality research institution in science can afford not to produce a Nobel laureate over long periods of time. It would clearly mean that Indian scientists are not thinking out of the box enough or not taking intellectual risks, qualities critical for the success of a research institution at a global level. Indians are dreaming on the past glory as leaders with no proper lead and support by their Institutions to restore the glory of the past.



An individual can make different kinds of contributions, but an institution has to produce different kinds of people. For a country with a large research infrastructure, a complete absence of Nobel Prize winners is a serious deficiency. There is only one Nobel Prize given in a field in a year, and that is why they should exercise caution before dismissing Indian science as not world class by pessimists.



Indian scientists and their work is not noticeable and recognizable at global level as compared to the work of the scientists from the West.  Dr. Chandra K Mittal, biotechnology professor living in Houston, Texas in an article has made it clear that many times Indian scientists do not get the required ‘ownership’ and ‘credit’ for their inputs in the original work. Mittal and Fervid Murad jointly did the work on the discovery of nitric oxide signaling system, but only Fervid Murad was awarded with the Nobel Prize not Mittal. Connection plays a significant role while selecting the name for Nobel Prize.  


Indian science has usually a follower and not a leader in the global arena today unlike in ancient times. And followers do not win Nobel Prizes. It takes great courage to continue working in a field with slim chances of success. James Rothman, who won 2013 prize in medicine, was told that he was “nuts” to attempt to reproduce the cell’s complexities. The US university system tolerates or even awards such courage, no matter what the results are. There is no such tolerance in India. Indian scientists are only encouraged to pursue safe lines of research that are guaranteed to result in publications. Unless institutions reward risk-taking, Indian science will follow and not lead.” May be that lead may come from Hindu Americans educated and living in USA.  I am not exaggerating! At the time when Dr. Hargobind Khurana won the Prize for medicine in 1968, Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar won for physics in 1983 and Venkatraman Ramakrishnan won Nobel Prize for chemistry in 2009, they were NRIs and residents of America not India. It was back in 1930 when Sir C.V. Raman an Indian resident won the Nobel Prize for Physics for “RAMAN” effect. But after him not even a single Indian has won this prestigious award in science. Do Indians lack in quality or the reason is something else?



“There is something wrong with respect to research and development in India after independence. In US research and development is still a part of Universities. Scientific discoveries from Universities travel to create technology and products. But in India, Universities which were responsible for research before independence no longer receive the required funds. Group of labs were formed under different scientists after independence. The top most scientific institutions receive most of the government funding for scientific development. On the other hand, Universities which used to work in this direction started getting fewer funds. This resulted in a great decline.

For quality, Universities and National Labs in India must work with close proximity to each other. Research and development must be revived in the Universities.



Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in 2010 stated red tape and political interference as the major reasons for the decline in the quality of Indian science.



“Real innovative brains of India either prefer to leave India or deprived of funds and information to carry out research and development. Most of the Indians are just interested in doing some secured job. Indians need to be more aggressive. We generally leave at the turning and at the most challenging point. Developed countries cross those challenging points and win. Much qualified students who are interested in research and development do not get direct seats into research labs and Universities in India. Political interference or strong backing play their role. Hence we are wasting our talent and mind. We must have a hunger to do the best. Education must be made available to every Indian child irrespective of gender, caste and creed.” writes Dinesh C Sharma.



Here are my Discourses and Compilations on Indian Science and Technology:











If you do not find time for all these pleas go through “A Very Brief History of Indian Science” by the reputed Indologist Subhash Kak delivered to Indian National Congress recently as given in the Appendix. Past glory will not bring laurels in the future automatically. We have to burn before we can shine!



APPENDIX I

A Very Brief History of Indian Science




The annual Indian Science Congress, which just concluded, had its usual share of controversies about history of Indian science and I have been asked to weigh in. It so turns out that I did precisely that in a brief account titled “Science” for Stanley Wolpert’s Encyclopedia of India (2005) and since that is freely available online, I shall be more selective of themes in this revision of the previous essay. This account does not include the modern period for which many excellent histories exist.

Indian archaeology and literature provide considerable layered evidence related to the development of science. The chronological time frame for this history is provided by the archaeological record that has been traced, in an unbroken tradition, to about 8000 BCE. Prior to this date, there are records of rock paintings that are considerably older. The earliest textual source is the igveda, which is a compilation of very ancient material. The astronomical references in the Vedic books recall events of the third or the fourth millennium BCE and earlier. The discovery that Sarasvati, the preeminent river of the igvedic times, went dry around 1900 BCE, if not earlier, suggests that portions of the igveda may be dated prior to this epoch.

The third millennium urbanization is characterized by a very precise system of weights and monumental architecture using cardinal directions. Indian writing (the so-called Indus script) goes back to the beginning of the third millennium BCE, but it has not yet been deciphered. However, statistical analysis shows that the later historical script called Brahmi evolved from this writing.

Laws and cosmology

The Vedic texts assert that the universe is governed by ta (laws) and that consciousness transcends materiality. The universe is taken to be infinite in size and infinitely old. By the time of the Purāas, other worlds were postulated beyond our solar system.

It is asserted that language (as a formal system) cannot describe reality completely and linguistic descriptions suffer from paradox. Because of this limitation, reality can only be experienced and never described fully. Knowledge was classified in two ways: the lower or dual अपरा; and the higher or unified परा. The seemingly irreconcilable worlds of the material and the conscious were taken as aspects of the connected. This connection is a consequence of a binding (bandhu) same transcendental reality.

The texts present a tripartite and recursive view of the world. The three regions of earth, space, and sky are mirrored in the human being in the physical body, the breath (prāa), and mind. The processes in the sky, on earth, and within the mind are assumed to between various inner and outer phenomena and it is because of this binding that it is possible to know the world.

There is evidence of the knowledge of biological cycles and awareness that there exist two fundamental rhythms in the body: the 24 hour related to the sun, and the 24 hour and 50 minute related to the period of the moon (the moon rises about 50 minutes later every day). This knowledge is not surprising since monthly rhythms, averaging 29.5 days, are reflected in the reproductive cycles of many marine plants and those of animals.

The gveda 10.90 speaks of these connections by saying that the moon was born of the mind and the sun was born of the eyes of the cosmic self:

candramā mana’so jāta | cako sūryo ajāyata | RV 10.90.13

The connection between the outer and the inner cosmos is seen most strikingly in the use of the number 108 in Indian religious and artistic expression. It was known that this number is the approximate distance from Earth to the sun and the moon, in sun and moon diameters, respectively. This number was probably obtained by taking a pole of a certain height to a distance 108 times its height and discovering that the angular size of the pole was the same as that of the sun or the moon. It is a curious fact that the diameter of the sun is also approximately 108 times the diameter of Earth.

This number of dance poses (karaas) given in the Nāya Śāstra is 108, as is the number of beads in a japamālā. The distance between the body and the inner sun is also taken to be 108, and thus there are 108 names of the gods and goddesses. The number of marmas (weak points) in Āyurveda is 107, because in a chain 108 units long, the number of weak points would be one less.


Physical laws and motion

The history of Indian physics goes back to Kaāda (कणाद) (~ 600 BCE) who asserted that all that is knowable is based on motion, thus giving centrality to analysis in the understanding of the universe.

Kaāda asserted that there are nine classes of substances: ether, space, and time, which are continuous, and four kinds of atoms two of which have mass and two that have little mass. A brilliant argument was given in support of this view.

Let the basic atoms of pthivī, āpas, tejas, and vāyu be represented by P, Ap, T, and V, respectively. Every substance is composed of these four kinds of atoms. Consider gold in its solid form; its mass derives principally from the P atoms. When it is heated, it becomes a liquid and therefore there should be another kind of an atom already in gold which makes it possible for it to take the liquid form and this is Ap. When heated further it burns and this is when the T atom gets manifested. When heated further, it loses its mass ever so slightly, and this is due to the loss of the V atoms.

The atoms are eternal only under normal conditions, and during creation and destruction, they arise in a sequence starting with ākāśa and are absorbed in the reverse sequence at the end of the world cycle. The sequence of evolution of the elements is given as VTApP. The V and T atoms have little mass (since they do not exist in a substantive form), whereas P and Ap atoms have mass. This sequence also hides within it the possibility of transformation from V and T atoms that are energetic to the more massive Ap and P atoms.

Kaāda also made a distinction between mind and the self, or consciousness. The conscious subject is separate from material reality but is, nevertheless, able to direct its evolution. He presented laws of motion and also spoke of invariants. He saw the atom to be spherical since it should appear the same from all directions.

The atoms combined to form different kinds of molecules that break up under the influence of heat. The molecules come to have different properties based on the influence of various potentials.

Indian chemistry developed many different alkalis, acids, and metallic salts by processes of calcination and distillation, often motivated by the need to formulate medicines. Metallurgists developed efficient techniques of extraction of metals from ore.

Astronomy

We know quite a bit about how astronomical science evolved in India. The Yajurvedic sage Yājñavalkya knew of a ninety-five-year cycle to harmonize the motions of the sun and the moon, and he also knew that the sun’s circuit was asymmetric. The second millennium BCE text Vedāga Jyotia of Lagadha went beyond the earlier calendrical astronomy to develop a theory for the mean motions of the sun and the moon. An epicycle theory was used to explain planetary motions. Given the different periods of the planets, it became necessary to assume yet longer periods to harmonize their cycles. This led to the notion of mahāyugas and kalpas with periods of billions of years.

The innovations of the division of the circle into 360 parts and the zodiac into 27 nakatras and 12 rāśis took place first in India. The schoolbook accounts of how these innovations first emerged in Mesopotamia in the 7th century BCE and then arrived in India centuries later are incorrect.

The Śatapatha Brāhmaa which was compiled soon after the Vedas says: The sun strings these worlds [the earth, the planets, the atmosphere] to himself on a thread. This thread is the same as the wind…” This suggests a central role to the sun in defining the motions of the planets and ideas such as these must have ultimately led to the theory of expanding and shrinking epicycles.

Astronomical texts called siddhāntas begin appearing sometime in the first millennium BCE. According to the tradition there were eighteen early siddhāntas, of which only a few have survived. Each siddhānta is an astronomical system with its own constants. The Sūrya Siddhānta speaks of the motion of planets governed by “cords of air” that bind them, which is a conception like that of the field.

The great astronomers and mathematicians include Āryabhaa (b. 476), who took Earth to spin on its own axis and who spoke of the relativity of motion and provided outer planet orbits with respect to the sun. This work and that of Brahmagupta (b. 598) and Bhāskara (b. 1114) was passed on to Europe via the Arabs. The Kerala School with figures such as Mādhava (c. 1340–1425) and Nīlakaṇṭha (c. 14441545) came up with new innovations of analysis based on advanced mathematics.

Evolution of Life

The Sākhya system speaks of evolution both at the levels of the individual as well as the cosmos. The Mahābhārata and the Purāas have material on creation and the rise of humankind. It is said that man arose at the end of a chain that began with plants and various kind of animals. In Vedic evolution the urge to evolve into higher forms is taken to be inherent in nature. A system of an evolution from inanimate to progressively higher life is assumed to be a consequence of the different proportions of the three basic attributes of the guas (qualities): sattva (truth or transparence), rajas (activity), and tamas (darkness or inertia). In its undeveloped state, cosmic matter has these qualities in equilibrium. As the world evolves, one or the other of these becomes preponderant in different objects or beings, giving specific character to each.

Geometry and mathematics

Indian geometry began very early in the Vedic period in altar problems, as in the one where the circular altar is to be made equal in area to a square altar. The historian of mathematics, Abraham Seidenberg, saw the birth of geometry and mathematics in the solution of such problems. Two aspects of the “Pythagoras” theorem are described in the texts by Baudhāyana and others. Problems are often presented with their algebraic counterparts. The solution to planetary problems also led to the development of algebraic methods.

Binary numbers were known at the time of Pigalas Chandaśāstra. Pigala, who might have lived as early as fourth century BCE used binary numbers to classify Vedic meters. The knowledge of binary numbers indicates a deep understanding of arithmetic.

The sign for zero within the place value decimal number system that was to revolutionize mathematics and facilitate development of technology appears to have been devised around 50 BCE to 50 CE. Indian numerals were introduced to Europe by Fibonacci (13th century) who is now known for a sequence that was described earlier by Virahaka (between 600 and 800), Gopāla (prior to 1135) and Hemacandra (~1150 CE). Nāryāna Paṇḍit (14th century) showed that these numbers were a special case of the multinomial coefficients.

Bharata’s Nāya Śāstra has results on combinatorics and discrete mathematics, and Āryabhaa has material on mathematics including methods to solve numerical problems effectively. Later source materials include the works of Brahmagupta, Lalla (eighth century), Mahāvīra (ninth century), Jayadeva, Śrīpati (eleventh century), Bhāskara, and Mādhava. In particular, Mādhava’s derivation and use of infinite series predated similar development in Europe, which is normally seen as the beginning of modern calculus. Some scholars believe these ideas were carried by Jesuits from India to Europe and they eventually set in motion the Scientific Revolution.

A noteworthy contribution was by the school of New Logic (Navya Nyāya) of Bengal and Bihar. At its zenith during the time of Raghunātha (1475–1550), this school developed a methodology for a precise semantic analysis of language. Navya Nyāya foreshadowed mathematical logic and there is evidence that it influenced modern machine theory.

Grammar

inis grammar Aṣṭādhyāyī (Eight chapters) of the fifth century BCE provides four thousand rules that describe Sanskrit completely. This grammar is acknowledged to be one of the greatest intellectual achievements of all time. The great variety of language mirrors, in many ways, the complexity of nature and, therefore, success in describing a language is as impressive as a complete theory of physics. Scholars have shown that the grammar of Pāini represents a universal grammatical and computing system. From this perspective, it anticipates the logical framework of modern computers.

Medicine

Āyurveda, the Indian medicine system, is a holistic approach to health that builds upon the tripartite Vedic approach to the world. Health is maintained through a balance between three basic humors (doa) of wind (vāta), fire (pitta), and water (kapha). Each of these humors had five varieties. Although literally meaning air, bile, and phlegm, the doas represented larger principles. Its division of states into three categories rather than two is more efficient than the binary division of other medicine systems.

Caraka and Suśruta are two famous early physicians. According to Caraka, health and disease are not predetermined, and life may be prolonged by human effort. Suśruta defines the purpose of medicine to cure the diseases of the sick, to protect the healthy, and to prolong life. The Sahitās speak of organisms that circulate in the blood, mucus, and phlegm. In particular, the organisms in the blood that cause disease are said to be invisible. It is suggested that physical contact and sharing the same air can cause such diseases to spread. Inoculation was practiced for protection against smallpox.

Indian surgery was quite advanced. The caesarian section was known, as was plastic surgery, and bone setting reached a high degree of skill. Suśruta classified surgical operations into eight categories: incision, excision, scarification, puncturing, probing, extraction, evacuation and drainage, and suturing. Suśruta lists 101 blunt and 20 sharp instruments that were used in surgery. The medical system tells us much about the Indian approach to science. There was emphasis on observation and experimentation.

Mind and consciousness

Vedic deities represent cognitive centers. It is asserted that parā-vidyā or ātma-vidyā (science of consciousness) cannot be described in words or design. In the Śrī-yantra, which is a representation of the cosmos, consciousness (Śiva) is shown as an infinitesimal dot in the middle.

The interaction between matter and consciousness is postulated in terms of an observation process called dṛṣṭi-sṛṣṭi (creation through observation), which is consistent with a world governed by laws. In the orthodox interpretation of quantum theory, consciousness is a separate category as in Vedanta.

Modern scientific subjects like physics, computer science, and neuroscience have been unable to explain the phenomenon of consciousness. Philosophy cannot reconcile our sense of freedom and agency with the framework of machine-like laws. In physical theory there is no place for the observer, computer science cannot explain how awareness arises in the brain machine, and neuroscience has not found any neural correlate of consciousness.

At the same time, the very association of information with physical systems as is done using entropy implies postulation of consciousness. So the use of the reductionist method in the analysis of consciousness has hit a wall.

Indian texts assert that the phenomenon of consciousness cannot be studied directly as a material property. Their analysis of consciousness using indirect methods may very well be relevant for further progress of this question in contemporary science.

Scientific speculations and more

Indian thought is unique in the breadth and scope of its scientific speculations that are scattered within its high literature. These range from airplanes (Rāmāyaa) to weapons that can destroy the world (Mahābhārata), and to the most astonishing abstract ideas in a text called Yoga-Vāsiṣṭha.

Many texts speak of the relativity of time and space — abstract concepts that developed in the scientific context just a hundred years ago. The Purāas describe countless universes and time flowing at different rates for different observers.

The Mahābhārata has an account of an embryo divided into one hundred parts each becoming, after maturation in a separate pot, a healthy baby; this is how the Kaurava brothers are born. There is also mention of a conception in one womb transferred to another: this is how Balarāma is a brother to Krishna although he was born to a different mother. This Epic has a major section on battle with a space ship whose occupants wear airtight suits (Saubha Parva). Are these to be seen as an early form of science fiction?

Universes defined recursively are described in the famous episode of Indra and the ants in Brahmavaivarta Purāa. Here Viṣṇu in the guise of a boy, explains to Indra that the ants he sees walking on the ground have all been Indras in their own solar systems in different times. These flights of imagination are more than a straightforward generalization of the motions of the planets into a cyclic universe.

The context of modern science fiction is clear: it is the liberation of the earlier modes of thought by the revolutionary developments of the 20th century science and technology. But how was science fiction integrated into the mainstream of Indian literary tradition over two thousand years ago? What was the intellectual ferment in which such sophisticated ideas arose?

Concluding, India’s civilization valued science and knowledge above all and some of the most extraordinary scientific advances took place there. These include the earliest astronomy, geometry, number theory, the Indian numeral system, the idea of physical laws and invariance, the earliest formal system to describe a complex natural phenomenon (as in Pāinis computer program-like grammar that was not rivaled for 2,500 years), a very subtle Yoga psychology, and the idea of immunization in medicine.



APPENDIX II

Microbiology Darwinism in Ancient Hindu Texts Vedas



 Ancient Vedic Indians, during the Vedic period have developed advanced knowledge in Microbiology.

 Biology and Surgery were developed and practiced.

 They knew the classification of Species.

Santi Parva of Mahabharata, Section XV Arjuna speaks of the world of Microbes, which “though not seen by the naked eyes, support Life”

Talks of Darwinism when he says that the strongest survive by feeding and annihilating them.

 The Mobile and the Immobile World is Food for Living creatures.

 Jainism had such an advanced knowledge and Piety, the Jain Monks use to sweep the path they travel gently with a fan made of Peacock feathers to make sure that the smaller organisms are not unintentionally killed by them.

 Kara, Dhooshana,  Inderjith and Ravana’s Moola Sena were adept at fighting biological warfare.

 Vedic literature recorded about 740 plants and 250 animals.

¨      The first attempt of classification is observed in Chandyogya Upanishad, which classified animals into three categories — Jivaja (Viviparous = giving birth to young ones), e.g. mammals, Andaja (Oviparous = egg lying), e.g. birds, reptiles, insects and worms, and Udbhija (Vegetal origin), e.g. minute animals. Post-Vedic Indian literature, such as Susruta Samhita (600 BC) classified all ‘substances’ into sthavara (immobile), e.g. plants, jangama (mobile), e.g. animals.

¨      Plants were further subdivided into Vanaspati (fruit yielding non-flowering plants),  Vriksha (both fruit yielding and flowering plants), Virudha (shrubs and creepers), and Osadhi (plants that die with ripening of fruits).

Susruta described in detail the parts of plants, such as Ankura (sprout), Mula (root), Kanda (bulb or stem), Patra (leaf), Pushpa (flower), Phala (fruit), etc.

¨      Susruta Samhita also mentioned about classification of animals, such as Kulachara (those herbivores who frequent the river banks, e.g. elephant, buffalo, etc.), Matsya (fish), Janghala (wild herbivorous quadrupeds, e.g. deer), Guhasaya (carnivorous quadrupeds like tiger, lion, etc.). Susruta Samhita also records some observations on snakes (both venomous and non-venomous) and leeches.

 They knew about Microbes and about fermentation.

They were aware of the exact combinations and temperatures at which fermentation takes place in preparing Buttermilk, Curds, and Liquor.

The existence of Lives, which are smaller and Microscopic was analyzed.

Germ theory of diseases was first established by Vedic Rishis and was recorded in Vedas.

Vedas are first text in the world to record nexus between microbes and disease.

In Vedas, prime etiological factors of diseases mentioned are–

 a) Endogenous toxins, its accumulations, and causation of a disease; b) ‘Krimi’ –’Drisya’ (visible), ‘Adrisya’ (invisible); and c) Imbalance of tridosha.

Rigveda, Yajurveda, and Atharvaveda followed by Āyurvedas provide rich insight into microbial sciences that existed in Bharat many thousands of years ago.

In Rigveda (1/191), Rishị Agastya pinpoints out that there are two types of poisonous creatures viz. those exceedingly poisonous and others are less poisonous.

Of them, some are visible venomous, while others are invisible one.

Some of them live in water, while others live on earth.

Perhaps Sage Agastya is the first person to state that invisible creatures are also toxin producers.

He also prescribes antidotes as remedy for the poison. Atharvaveda reiterates that whenever there is accumulation of toxins within the body, disease results.

Use of Biological weapons of Mass Destruction was known.

There are large number of suktas in the Vedas which provides information about microbiological knowledge in the ancient Vedic texts.

Kankotan Sukta by Rishi Agastaya (Rigveda 1/191); Krimighnam Sukta (Atharvaveda 5/23), Krim nashnamSukta (AV. 2/32), Krim-jambhanamSukta

(AV. 2/31) all by Rishi Kanva; Rakshognam Sukta (AV. 5/29) by Rishi Chatan; KriminashnamSukta (AV. 4/37) by Rishi Badrayani and other suktas provides insight into the Microbial sciences in Vedas.

Not only the Vedas, Ayurvedic texts like Charaka Samhita, Susruta Samhita, Ashtanga Hridaya and many others provides rich insight into Vedic Microbiology.







No comments:

Post a Comment